Should Airbnb refund the “biggest cockroach I’ve seen in my life”?

DEAR TRAVEL CAREER: I recently booked an Airbnb rental in Tallahassee, Florida. A few hours after arriving I was in the kitchen and saw the biggest cockroach I have ever seen in my life.
There was no insecticide and my boyfriend couldn’t kill him. It flowed under the island. I didn’t feel safe and I was afraid that cockroaches would come into my things.

Christopher Elliott, the travel convenience store

The host offered me a different rental, but I didn’t hear from him for four hours. So we left the rental and settled in a hotel.

I contacted Airbnb, who offered to reimburse the cleaning fee. I asked to speak to a supervisor and sent a complaint to the Better Business Bureau (BBB). A supervisor contacted me four days ago to arrange an appointment and I responded with my availability. No one has contacted me since. It seems almost impossible to talk to someone to solve this problem. I would like to get back the $614 I spent on the rental. Can you help ?

—Maulah Halley, Brooklyn Park, Minnesota

REPLY: Do you deserve a full refund for discovering a cockroach in your Florida rental? I am not sure. But I’m afraid you had trouble getting in touch with someone at Airbnb. And I also wanted to know how big the cockroach was. So I decided to take your case.

You sent me a photo. It was very big.

I remember encountering one of these insects when I stayed at a hostel in New Orleans in the 1980s. I kicked it hard with a shoe, and it ran off, unfazed. Scary.

But as your host noted in email correspondence with you, cockroaches — or saw palmetto bugs — are common in North Florida. This does not necessarily mean that the whole rental is infested or that you will see one again.

You did well to immediately contact the host and Airbnb. You may have given the host the opportunity to treat the living spaces with an insecticide. But Airbnb’s refund policy (available at www.airbnb.com/help/article/2868/rebooking-and-refund-policy) specifically covers dwellings that present safety or health hazards, or pests. You may have argued that a cockroach—sorry, a saw palmetto insect—was both a health hazard and a pest.

Comments are closed.